[prev in list] [next in list] [prev in thread] [next in thread] 

List:       kde-core-devel
Subject:    Re: Ugh... Qt4 porting
From:       Mosfet <dan.duley () verizon ! net>
Date:       2005-05-16 12:55:30
Message-ID: 200505160755.30321.dan.duley () verizon ! net
[Download RAW message or body]

Hi Lars! You guys really need to start CCing me. I'm not on the list so am 
cutting and pasting responses from the mailing list archive ;-)

>Lars wrote:
...snip...
>> I'm also curious about what they are going to do with the new Premultiplied
>> format. As far as I can tell it's a 32bpp format with the source part of
>> the alpha already calculated. Good if your going to alphablend the image a
>> lot, bad if you want to modify the original color channels. 
>
>The image paint engine uses it. All drawing operations are a lot faster when 
>using premultiplied alpha. It's also the format used by RENDER, so it matches 
>fine there as well.
>
>And I don't see why you shouldn't be able to modify the color channels in a 
>premultiplied image more or less the same way then in a non premultiplied 
>one.

Because a pixel's RGB values aren't the actual RGB values, they are averaged 
with the alpha value. So if your doing something like interpolating a color 
you'd be interpolating with the wrong color, no? Even simple things like the 
gray level would be wrong. A red value of 25 may actually be 100 but with 
1/4th the opacity. Most effects won't work properly with this.

>> Right now I just return if I get one of these.
>
>QImage has a convertToFormat() method you could use: Convert to a format you 
>can handle, and convert back at the end. Not fast, but maybe better than just 
>not doing anything.
 
We promote images to 32bpp when we have to but generally do not do things that 
require a lot of conversion, for example we don't do effects on 1bpp images 
by promoting them. I guess it would depend on how often it is used. Doing so 
will kill performance, and in such cases the approach has been that it's 
better to warn the developer.

[prev in list] [next in list] [prev in thread] [next in thread]