[prev in list] [next in list] [prev in thread] [next in thread] 

List:       zodb-checkins
Subject:    [Zodb-checkins] SVN: ZODB/trunk/doc/guide/modules.tex Explain why
From:       Tim Peters <tim.one () comcast ! net>
Date:       2004-05-14 21:34:07
Message-ID: 200405142134.i4ELY7sK011714 () cvs ! zope ! org
[Download RAW message or body]

Log message for revision 24695:
Explain why it's a Bad Idea to use a persistent object as a BTree key.


-=-
Modified: ZODB/trunk/doc/guide/modules.tex
===================================================================
--- ZODB/trunk/doc/guide/modules.tex	2004-05-14 21:08:34 UTC (rev 24694)
+++ ZODB/trunk/doc/guide/modules.tex	2004-05-14 21:34:06 UTC (rev 24695)
@@ -360,9 +360,30 @@
        Any part of a comparison implementation that relies (explicitly
        or implicitly) on an address-based comparison result will
        eventually cause serious failure.
+
+\item  Do not use \class{Persistent} objects as keys, or objects of a
+       subclass of \class{Persistent}.
 \end{enumerate}
 
+That last item may be surprising.  It stems from details of how
+conflict resolution is implemented:  the states passed to conflict
+resolution do not materialize persistent subobjects (if a persistent
+object P is a key in a BTree, then P is a subobject of the bucket
+containing P).  Instead, if an object O references a persistent subobject
+P directly, and O is involved in a conflict, the states passed to
+conflict resolution contain an instance of an internal
+\class{PersistentReference} stub class everywhere O references P.
+Two \class{PersistentReference} instances compare equal if and only if
+they "represent" the same persistent object; when they're not equal,
+they compare by memory address, and, as expalined before, memory-based
+comparison must never happen in a sane persistent BTree.  Note that it
+doesn't help in this case if your \class{Persistent} subclass defines
+a sane \method{__cmp__()} method:  conflict resolution doesn't know
+about your class, and so also doesn't know about its \method{__cmp__()}
+method.  It only sees instances of the internal \class{PersistentReference}
+stub class.
 
+
 \subsubsection{Iteration and Mutation}
 
 As with a Python dictionary or list, you should not mutate a BTree-based


_______________________________________________
Zodb-checkins mailing list
Zodb-checkins@zope.org
http://mail.zope.org/mailman/listinfo/zodb-checkins
[prev in list] [next in list] [prev in thread] [next in thread]