[prev in list] [next in list] [prev in thread] [next in thread]
List: ms-ospf
Subject: Re: What will happen in this kind of topology with 100 nbrs and 2000 ASEs ??
From: Sean Andersen <farshad () ONEBOX ! COM>
Date: 2004-10-26 0:04:36
Message-ID: B0035909846 () vljcms10 ! ucmretail ! internal ! callsciences ! com
[Download RAW message or body]
Mollin,
I agree with every answer sent so far. But here is one more thing to look at: Have \
you checked the GIG link to see if it is flapping? I know of some vendors (will not \
name names here) that still have some issues/compatibiliy on the Gig links and flap \
up and down constantly.
Sean
-----Original Message-----
From: Mollin, Arvind - LiqwidKrystal <arvindmollin@RIVERSTONENET.COM>
Sent: Sun, 24 Oct 2004 21:42:12 -0700
To: OSPF@PEACH.EASE.LSOFT.COM
Subject: What will happen in this kind of topology with 100 nbrs and 2000 ASEs ??
Hi,
I have two routers connected back to back through a gig link. I have
configured 100 VLANs in that single gig link, now each vlan act as
virtual interface. I have configured 100 neighbors on each router using
these 100 virtual interfaces. All the neighbors are in backbone. See the
figure below,
( 100 nbrs )R1 -------------100 vlans ------------------ R2 ( 100 nbrs )
After sometime I could see all nbrs flapping often. What could be the
reason for this ??
Is this topology right?, Has anybody tested with this kind of setup ??
Thanks
Arvind
["200410252018.html" (text/html)]
ÿþ< h t m l x m l n s : o = " u r n : s c h e m a s - m i c r o s o f t - c o m : o f f i c e : o f f i c e " \
x m l n s : w = " u r n : s c h e m a s - m i c r o s o f t - c o m : o f f i c e : w o r d " \
x m l n s = " h t t p : / / w w w . w 3 . o r g / T R / R E C - h t m l 4 0 " >
< h e a d >
< M E T A H T T P - E Q U I V = " C o n t e n t - T y p e " \
C O N T E N T = " t e x t / h t m l ; c h a r s e t = u s - a s c i i " >
< m e t a n a m e = G e n e r a t o r c o n t e n t = " M i c r o s o f t \
W o r d 1 1 ( f i l t e r e d m e d i u m ) " >
< s t y l e >
< ! - -
/ * S t y l e D e f i n i t i o n s * /
p . M s o N o r m a l , l i . M s o N o r m a l , d i v . M s o N o r m a l
{ m a r g i n : 0 i n ;
m a r g i n - b o t t o m : . 0 0 0 1 p t ;
f o n t - s i z e : 1 2 . 0 p t ;
f o n t - f a m i l y : " T i m e s N e w R o m a n " ; }
h 1
{ m a r g i n - t o p : 1 2 . 0 p t ;
m a r g i n - r i g h t : 0 i n ;
m a r g i n - b o t t o m : 3 . 0 p t ;
m a r g i n - l e f t : . 2 5 i n ;
t e x t - i n d e n t : - . 2 5 i n ;
p a g e - b r e a k - a f t e r : a v o i d ;
m s o - l i s t : l 0 l e v e l 1 l f o 1 ;
f o n t - s i z e : 2 0 . 0 p t ;
f o n t - f a m i l y : A r i a l ; }
a : l i n k , s p a n . M s o H y p e r l i n k
{ c o l o r : b l u e ;
t e x t - d e c o r a t i o n : u n d e r l i n e ; }
a : v i s i t e d , s p a n . M s o H y p e r l i n k F o l l o w e d
{ c o l o r : p u r p l e ;
t e x t - d e c o r a t i o n : u n d e r l i n e ; }
p . M s o P l a i n T e x t , l i . M s o P l a i n T e x t , \
d i v . M s o P l a i n T e x t
{ m a r g i n : 0 i n ;
m a r g i n - b o t t o m : . 0 0 0 1 p t ;
f o n t - s i z e : 1 0 . 0 p t ;
f o n t - f a m i l y : " C o u r i e r N e w " ; }
p . F i g u r e , l i . F i g u r e , d i v . F i g u r e
{ m a r g i n - t o p : 0 i n ;
m a r g i n - r i g h t : 0 i n ;
m a r g i n - b o t t o m : 0 i n ;
m a r g i n - l e f t : 2 . 0 i n ;
m a r g i n - b o t t o m : . 0 0 0 1 p t ;
f o n t - s i z e : 1 6 . 0 p t ;
f o n t - f a m i l y : " C o u r i e r N e w " ; }
s p a n . E m a i l S t y l e 1 9
{ m s o - s t y l e - t y p e : p e r s o n a l - c o m p o s e ;
f o n t - f a m i l y : A r i a l ;
c o l o r : w i n d o w t e x t ; }
@ p a g e S e c t i o n 1
{ s i z e : 8 . 5 i n 1 1 . 0 i n ;
m a r g i n : 1 . 0 i n 1 . 2 5 i n 1 . 0 i n 1 . 2 5 i n ; }
d i v . S e c t i o n 1
{ p a g e : S e c t i o n 1 ; }
/ * L i s t D e f i n i t i o n s * /
@ l i s t l 0
{ m s o - l i s t - i d : 3 8 3 5 2 4 9 8 1 ;
m s o - l i s t - t e m p l a t e - i d s : - 2 1 4 3 3 9 8 1 9 0 ; }
@ l i s t l 0 : l e v e l 1
{ m s o - l e v e l - s t y l e - l i n k : " H e a d i n g 1 " ;
m s o - l e v e l - t a b - s t o p : . 2 5 i n ;
m s o - l e v e l - n u m b e r - p o s i t i o n : l e f t ;
m a r g i n - l e f t : . 2 5 i n ;
t e x t - i n d e n t : - . 2 5 i n ; }
@ l i s t l 0 : l e v e l 2
{ m s o - l e v e l - t e x t : " % 1 \ . % 2 \ . " ;
m s o - l e v e l - t a b - s t o p : . 5 5 i n ;
m s o - l e v e l - n u m b e r - p o s i t i o n : l e f t ;
m a r g i n - l e f t : . 5 5 i n ;
t e x t - i n d e n t : - . 3 i n ; }
@ l i s t l 0 : l e v e l 3
{ m s o - l e v e l - t e x t : " % 1 \ . % 2 \ . % 3 \ . " ;
m s o - l e v e l - t a b - s t o p : 1 . 0 i n ;
m s o - l e v e l - n u m b e r - p o s i t i o n : l e f t ;
m a r g i n - l e f t : . 8 5 i n ;
t e x t - i n d e n t : - . 3 5 i n ; }
@ l i s t l 0 : l e v e l 4
{ m s o - l e v e l - t e x t : " % 1 \ . % 2 \ . % 3 \ . % 4 \ . " ;
m s o - l e v e l - t a b - s t o p : 1 . 2 5 i n ;
m s o - l e v e l - n u m b e r - p o s i t i o n : l e f t ;
m a r g i n - l e f t : 1 . 2 i n ;
t e x t - i n d e n t : - . 4 5 i n ; }
@ l i s t l 0 : l e v e l 5
{ m s o - l e v e l - t e x t : " % 1 \ . % 2 \ . % 3 \ . % 4 \ . % 5 \ . " ;
m s o - l e v e l - t a b - s t o p : 1 . 7 5 i n ;
m s o - l e v e l - n u m b e r - p o s i t i o n : l e f t ;
m a r g i n - l e f t : 1 . 5 5 i n ;
t e x t - i n d e n t : - . 5 5 i n ; }
@ l i s t l 0 : l e v e l 6
{ m s o - l e v e l - t e x t : " % 1 \ . % 2 \ . % 3 \ . % 4 \ . % 5 \ . % 6 \ . " ;
m s o - l e v e l - t a b - s t o p : 2 . 0 i n ;
m s o - l e v e l - n u m b e r - p o s i t i o n : l e f t ;
m a r g i n - l e f t : 1 . 9 i n ;
t e x t - i n d e n t : - . 6 5 i n ; }
@ l i s t l 0 : l e v e l 7
{ m s o - l e v e l - t e x t : " % 1 \ . % 2 \ . % 3 \ . % 4 \ . % 5 \ . % 6 \ . % 7 \ . " ;
m s o - l e v e l - t a b - s t o p : 2 . 5 i n ;
m s o - l e v e l - n u m b e r - p o s i t i o n : l e f t ;
m a r g i n - l e f t : 2 . 2 5 i n ;
t e x t - i n d e n t : - . 7 5 i n ; }
@ l i s t l 0 : l e v e l 8
{ m s o - l e v e l - t e x t : " % 1 \ . % 2 \ . % 3 \ . % 4 \ . % 5 \ . % 6 \ . % 7 \ . % 8 \ . " ;
m s o - l e v e l - t a b - s t o p : 2 . 7 5 i n ;
m s o - l e v e l - n u m b e r - p o s i t i o n : l e f t ;
m a r g i n - l e f t : 2 . 6 i n ;
t e x t - i n d e n t : - . 8 5 i n ; }
@ l i s t l 0 : l e v e l 9
{ m s o - l e v e l - t e x t : " % 1 \ . % 2 \ . % 3 \ . % 4 \ . % 5 \ . % 6 \ . % 7 \ . % 8 \ . % 9 \ . " ;
m s o - l e v e l - t a b - s t o p : 3 . 2 5 i n ;
m s o - l e v e l - n u m b e r - p o s i t i o n : l e f t ;
m a r g i n - l e f t : 3 . 0 i n ;
t e x t - i n d e n t : - 1 . 0 i n ; }
o l
{ m a r g i n - b o t t o m : 0 i n ; }
u l
{ m a r g i n - b o t t o m : 0 i n ; }
- - >
< / s t y l e >
< / h e a d >
< b o d y l a n g = E N - U S l i n k = b l u e v l i n k = p u r p l e >
< d i v c l a s s = S e c t i o n 1 >
< p c l a s s = M s o N o r m a l > < f o n t s i z e = 2 \
f a c e = A r i a l > < s p a n s t y l e = ' f o n t - s i z e : 1 0 . 0 p t ;
f o n t - f a m i l y : A r i a l ' > H i , < o : p > < / o : p > < / s p a n > < / f o n t > < / p >
< p c l a s s = M s o N o r m a l > < f o n t s i z e = 2 \
f a c e = A r i a l > < s p a n s t y l e = ' f o n t - s i z e : 1 0 . 0 p t ;
f o n t - f a m i l y : A r i a l ' > & n b s p ; I h a v e t w o \
r o u t e r s c o n n e c t e d b a c k t o b a c k t h r o u g h a \
g i g
l i n k . I h a v e c o n f i g u r e d 1 0 0 V L A N s i n t h a t \
s i n g l e g i g l i n k , n o w e a c h v l a n a c t a s
v i r t u a l i n t e r f a c e . I h a v e c o n f i g u r e d 1 0 0 \
n e i g h b o r s o n e a c h r o u t e r u s i n g t h e s e
1 0 0 v i r t u a l i n t e r f a c e s . A l l t h e n e i g h b o r s \
a r e i n b a c k b o n e . S e e t h e f i g u r e
b e l o w , < o : p > < / o : p > < / s p a n > < / f o n t > < / p >
< p c l a s s = M s o N o r m a l > < f o n t s i z e = 2 \
f a c e = A r i a l > < s p a n s t y l e = ' f o n t - s i z e : 1 0 . 0 p t ;
f o n t - f a m i l y : A r i a l ' > < o : p > & n b s p ; < / o : p > < / s p a n > < / f o n t > < / p >
< p c l a s s = M s o N o r m a l > < f o n t s i z e = 2 \
f a c e = A r i a l > < s p a n s t y l e = ' f o n t - s i z e : 1 0 . 0 p t ;
f o n t - f a m i l y : A r i a l ' > ( 1 0 0 n b r s ) R 1 \
- - - - - - - - - - - - - 1 0 0 v l a n s - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - \
R 2
( 1 0 0 n b r s ) < o : p > < / o : p > < / s p a n > < / f o n t > < / p >
< p c l a s s = M s o N o r m a l > < f o n t s i z e = 2 \
f a c e = A r i a l > < s p a n s t y l e = ' f o n t - s i z e : 1 0 . 0 p t ;
f o n t - f a m i l y : A r i a l ' > < o : p > & n b s p ; < / o : p > < / s p a n > < / f o n t > < / p >
< p c l a s s = M s o N o r m a l > < f o n t s i z e = 2 \
f a c e = A r i a l > < s p a n s t y l e = ' f o n t - s i z e : 1 0 . 0 p t ;
f o n t - f a m i l y : A r i a l ' > A f t e r s o m e t i m e I c o u l d \
s e e a l l n b r s f l a p p i n g o f t e n . W h a t
c o u l d b e t h e r e a s o n f o r t h i s \
? ? < o : p > < / o : p > < / s p a n > < / f o n t > < / p >
< p c l a s s = M s o N o r m a l > < f o n t s i z e = 2 \
f a c e = A r i a l > < s p a n s t y l e = ' f o n t - s i z e : 1 0 . 0 p t ;
f o n t - f a m i l y : A r i a l ' > I s t h i s t o p o l o g y \
r i g h t ? , H a s a n y b o d y t e s t e d w i t h t h i s k i n d
o f s e t u p ? ? < o : p > < / o : p > < / s p a n > < / f o n t > < / p >
< p c l a s s = M s o N o r m a l > < f o n t s i z e = 2 \
f a c e = A r i a l > < s p a n s t y l e = ' f o n t - s i z e : 1 0 . 0 p t ;
f o n t - f a m i l y : A r i a l ' > < o : p > & n b s p ; < / o : p > < / s p a n > < / f o n t > < / p >
< p c l a s s = M s o N o r m a l > < f o n t s i z e = 2 \
f a c e = A r i a l > < s p a n s t y l e = ' f o n t - s i z e : 1 0 . 0 p t ;
f o n t - f a m i l y : A r i a l ' > T h a n k s < o : p > < / o : p > < / s p a n > < / f o n t > < / p >
< p c l a s s = M s o N o r m a l > < f o n t s i z e = 2 \
f a c e = A r i a l > < s p a n s t y l e = ' f o n t - s i z e : 1 0 . 0 p t ;
f o n t - f a m i l y : A r i a l ' > A r v i n d < o : p > < / o : p > < / s p a n > < / f o n t > < / p >
< p c l a s s = M s o N o r m a l > < f o n t s i z e = 2 \
f a c e = A r i a l > < s p a n s t y l e = ' f o n t - s i z e : 1 0 . 0 p t ;
f o n t - f a m i l y : A r i a l ' > < o : p > & n b s p ; < / o : p > < / s p a n > < / f o n t > < / p >
< / d i v >
< / b o d y >
< / h t m l >
[prev in list] [next in list] [prev in thread] [next in thread]
Configure |
About |
News |
Add a list |
Sponsored by KoreLogic