Uno Engborg wrote:

> The problem with auto generated favorits is that the user loses, control 
> over what shows up in them. What is every day tasks may change over 
> time, and as they do, the menus will change with them. At first thought 
> this might seam like a good idea, but in reality it means that the user 
> needs to make sure that the menu hasn't changed every time he uses it. 
> This means that he can't make use of motoric memory.

You are correct about the disadvantages of a menu that constantly 
changes.  However, we have a problem with the large K-Menu that lists 
every app installed on the system.  I have found that motoric memory 
works even on this large menu but it is still a pain to find apps in it 
even when your muscle memory knows where they are.

What we need to find is something that is workable.  Like any 
engineering problem, the solution will not be perfect -- it only needs 
to be optimum (the best solution which may only be the least bad solution).

I would find my proposal with the retention time set to 3 days to be 
totally acceptable but some users might like it.  However, with a 
retention time of 30 days (or more) the menu would not change much and 
this would allow motoric memory to a large extent.

OTOH, some users might not want an automatic menu and they could set the 
retention time to 0 days and manually select those apps which they 
wanted included in the short menu.

-- 
JRT
_______________________________________________
kde-usability mailing list
kde-usability@kde.org
https://mail.kde.org/mailman/listinfo/kde-usability