Hi Jay,

>  - Re-Use of Parameter Information
> You can see there are lines within gmic_def.NNNN that define "Poster Edges"
> filter and also specifies the types and ranges of the input variables.  The
> gmic_gimp plugin uses those definitions to present a user interface.
> Perhaps "#@gimp" lines should change to "#@interface" or something more
> Krita friendly.

Krita friendly? It's ok to let it be :)

>  - Version Control of Core "DEF" file
> If you did split-out just those parts of the gmic_def then you may need to
> maintain your fork

I don't want to fork at all.
I'd like to be able to link dynamically against gmic,
so that Linux distributions provide always up-to-date
gmic.

>  - Rewriting 8-bit scripts : TO DO
> Since 2.9/2.10 are moving to higher bit depth and deprecating the existing
> plugin interface, it seems likely a GMIC Script GEGL node will be made that
> always requests a 32bit-float RGBA format, in which case many GMIC scripts
> that assume a 0-255 8bit value from the current plug-in will need to be
> amended to cope.

It's little bit confusing with 255.0 values of pixels and this options
and 8-bit encoding.

GMIC is using Float32 bit internally but expect that the picture is in range
0.0 - 255.0 to work nicely with parameters of filters.

Krita is representing pixel in Float32 in range 0.0-1.0.
So for now I normalize it on input and output.
David showed me command in gmic that can do that, no problem.

>  - ColourSpace Assumption
> As far as I understand values passed from GIMP are for an sRGB Colourspace
> but most of the plugins currently make no adjustment to linearise before
> processing - this is something better curation of filters could solve.

Do we need linear rgb? What would be the real benefits for users?


> There are also some "features" of the Alpha channel handling.  Most scripts
> that ignore Alpha will delete the transparency rather than retain it.
> Again, it's a matter of curation.

Uh, good to know this! Thanks!

> I'd be interested in a more database driven system to track versions of
> filters and maximise user interaction.  There was something in KDE that Boud
> mentioned at LGM as being worth looking at but I am a Windows user myself
> and have not found it yet.  A hosted repository with some kind of upload,
> search, tagging, user-feedback but also version control and regression
> testing would seem desirable in addition to curation metadata about
> colourspace and transparency etc..

GetHotNewStuff http://ghns.freedesktop.org/

Regards,
Lukas
_______________________________________________
Krita mailing list
kimageshop@kde.org
https://mail.kde.org/mailman/listinfo/kimageshop