On Saturday 30 January 2010, PEGON Marc wrote:
> I'm trying to make the local selections work according to
> https://bugs.kde.org/show_bug.cgi?id=210865
> But the way these local selections should work is still quite vague, so
> i would like your advice, especially about boud's suggestion to add a
> third icon to enable/disable selection...
> Some people are concerned about the fact that a third icon might make
> the use of local selections too complicated for users, however, i'm not
> sure it's possible to handle the local selections nicely only with the
> visibility icon (plus marching ant animation are sometimes disturbing,
> and people want to be able to hide it without disabling the selection).

Yes, that's the reason. I don't think an extra icon nin the layerbox is such a 
big thing. I also added the alpha lock icon for ordinary layers, and I'm sure 
there will be some more for things as yet unforeseen.

> Also, i'm not sure what the actions "Deselect" and "Deselect all" should
> do in particular cases. For example, if i make a selection (a global
> selection), and then create a local selection mask from this global
> selection, then i have 2 selections enabled at the same time : the
> global selection, and the local selection (which are the same). It's the
> local selection which is used preferentially : if a local selection
> exists and is enabled, then it's the one which is returned by
> KisLayer::selection(). But then, what should the "Deselect" action do ?
> Disable the local selection ? Disable the global selection ?

Remove the global selection, I'd say. The local selection can be removed with 
the delete node button in the layerbox.

> Problem is, whether we choose to disable the local selection or the
> global selection, we would have to do "Deselect" twice in order to see a
> difference : indeed, if you disable the global selection, the local
> selection remains here and enabled, so you have to do "deselect" on more
> time to deselect the local selection.

I don't think that deselect should work on local selections. Deleting the node 
seems more intuitive to me.

> So maybe we should Disable both ? (but then we would have to add a new
> kis command since neither kis_deselect_local_selection_command nor
> kis_deselect_global_selection_command matches this new command).
> Another solution is to disable the global selection when creating a
> local selection from it, or when enabling an existing local selection,
> so that there are never a global selection and a local selection active
> at the same time.

Hm, that might actually work pretty well. I guess we could make a config 
setting for that behaviour, so we can experiment with it.

> Another thing : what should happen when using the selection tool ?
> should it modify the current local selection if one is enabled, and
> create a global selection if none is enabled ?

Yes -- and if the local selection is selected in the layerbox, the painting 
tools should work on it.

> 
> I really need clarifications on this to do anything. Thanks !

Thanks for your effort, and I'm really sorry I wasn't available this weekend 
:-(.

-- 
Boudewijn Rempt | http://www.valdyas.org
_______________________________________________
kimageshop mailing list
kimageshop@kde.org
https://mail.kde.org/mailman/listinfo/kimageshop