From kde-i18n-doc Sun Oct 26 16:35:50 2003 From: Henrique Pinto Date: Sun, 26 Oct 2003 16:35:50 +0000 To: kde-i18n-doc Subject: Re: "Folder" or "Directory"? X-MARC-Message: https://marc.info/?l=kde-i18n-doc&m=106718902922450 On Sunday 26 October 2003 16:12, Andrea Rizzi wrote: > I simply said that the "new directory" create a "folder icon" is not an > argument to change "directory" to "folder" everywhere. > Personally I agree that changing "directory" to "folder" whenever > possible, is good for usability (so it is "Create new folder"). > In the "home directory" context it seems that "home folder" is not so > good, in kde-core-devel thread about "Home Folder" only Craig (and last > Waldo mail) seem to be for "Home folder" while many others think that > "home directory" is too related to the OS (and so much used, see Dirk > mail) and should remain... but it is already moved to "Home folder" > (see kuser.po). Consistency is a must in usability. If you are adopting "folder", then use "folder" everywhere. Using "directory" in some cases will lead to a inconsistent desktop, what is not the goal of KDE. If there are going to be exceptions, maybe it is better to revert all changes, thus having a consistent environment (with "directory" refering o filesystem entities and "folder" refering to virtual non-fs related directories). I agree that saying that "new directory" creates a "folder icon" is not an argument for changing "directory" to "folder" everywhere. However, as usability tests pointed out, users feel confused by 'directory'. Both 'directory' and 'folder' are abstractions to the concept. 'Folder' seems easier for potential users to understand. That's why I think the choice of 'folder' was correct. BTW, a globe icon is also a good metaphor to the Internet, so there's no need to change it. This discussion is becoming off-topic for this list. If you feel the need for continuing it, feel free to post to kde-usability (or even to me directly). Thank you for your time. -- Henrique Pinto stampede@uai.com.br