From kde-extra-gear  Thu Mar 08 13:13:54 2007
From: Angelo Naselli <anaselli () linux ! it>
Date: Thu, 08 Mar 2007 13:13:54 +0000
To: kde-extra-gear
Subject: Re: [Kde-extra-gear] Rethinking position on trunk x branches
Message-Id: <loom.20070308T140430-658 () post ! gmane ! org>
X-MARC-Message: https://marc.info/?l=kde-extra-gear&m=117336002425135

Hi,

> 
> Hi people ( again )
> 
> Sharing ideas with some guys, specially the translators around me and 
> sysadmin, i will step up on the subject and change the idea about branch for 
> kde4.
> 
> Please follow this line of thinking: Doesn't make sense develop old ( as a 
> current release ) kde3 development on trunk HEAD and put the new ( as a 
> future release ) on branch.
> We're rowling against flow, since translator always look for head and one 
> stable branch.
> Creating the kde4 branch, we will create a 3rd copy of keg, and probably we 
> will loose people because or lack of motivation or simple basic confusion on 
> where to get and put things...
> 
> So let's put the things on the right path.
> Trunk will be kde4.
> branches/stable to continue develop against kde3 ? Dirk, some suggestion ?
> 
> My only question is, how much time you want to prepare for this move. 
> I want to do it asap, on next monday, as in term of official announce and 
help 
> to port cmake things.
> 
> So, thanks for all listening and let's start the cry out 
> 

As asked, I'm back on this subject following the old thread.
As far as I'm concerned I don't mind to branch keg either for kde4 
or for kde3 svn should be easy to use to manage for that. 
But I believe the way to is to branch all the keg.
If someone cannot work on kde4 yet can disable his/her application
to be built. AFAIK kde-i18n is breanching (or has already) so why
not following their example? If they've chosen to stay in trunk for 
stable we can do that either.

As I told you in mine first, It seems silly to me branching every
single keg application.

Waiting for comments my best,
    Angelo


_______________________________________________
Kde-extra-gear mailing list
Kde-extra-gear@kde.org
https://mail.kde.org/mailman/listinfo/kde-extra-gear