-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----

Hiya,

> My new reasoning would be more along the lines of: what the user 
> _voluntarily_ selects gets copied.

that's exactly the reason for the option "Setting Clipboard implicitly sets 
Selection". Whenever I explicitly perform a "Copy" action, be it Ctrl-C/X or 
a "Copy" in a menubar or contextmenu, I expect being able to paste that with 
both MMB and Ctrl-V (or "Paste" in a menubar).

I see MMB as a convenience method for pasting stuff when my fingers are not 
resting on Ctrl-V.

So, ideally, I would see this whole Selection-thing being removed altogether, 
i.e. you always have to press Cltr-C to put something into the clipboard. 
Exceptions are terminal programs where Ctrl-C is already taken of course.

This might be a radical change for some, but that's my view. IMHO quite easy 
to understand for the user. And I haven't seen a Windows-user complaining 
that he has to press Ctrl-C for copying.

Cheers
Carsten Pfeiffer
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----

iQEVAwUBPcMfmaWgYMJuwmZtAQHyDQf+KR/KL1UfabQFmlTyiDZOvwBDsPU6dnUv
dIOc9kyR4u1Ui75CSmoguyhkwBcXAc1ofzHuNpNSyv7TkUP5sM2oY11bpo9O5UWR
/Xbpjq3qXkkTn23Fbm3glkJhp5jKtu+N0sAhKNZx0i21xBZ2jYppiZeyOXM+Btjm
jXZ8PlVS2O7jgXZZqP3Pga4J8bR3iYxlfqCqLLnr2KxxnaXkqEDNQ5KGm6nDpzH6
v5zQym3Y17pEKLOiQ1tF8TA+/eK5XewN8nZW+qDKymFPIcMCs/EYwDT6tOb+YX4Q
opkvaVPJhpqATdzHPLMNjPDMfEg3QE5VB74Pe9bzfZSLYox/ixcoAg==
=q91m
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----