Hi Nuno,

thanks for your reply.

Am Mittwoch, 9. Januar 2013, 13:08:39 schrieb Nuno Pinheiro:
> A Ter=E7a, 8 de Janeiro de 2013 21:01:02 Friedrich W. H. Kossebau escreve=
u:
> =

> what ever you guys fal its best,

Okay, so I am going to remove the icons
	oxygen-icons/*/apps/karbon.png
	oxygen-icons/*/apps/kexi.png
	oxygen-icons/*/apps/krita.png
from the oxygen iconset in the next days, both from trunk and the 4.10 bran=
ch.

> im tempeted to say that ith the icons are
> good enough you could ship them upstream to oxygen, i will probably aprove
> them..
> =

> btw can i see the new icons?

They are the ones you can see at the header of http://www.calligra.org/ , i=
.e. =

the ones which once were made for the apps in KOffice IIRC, but now e.g. =

without the small KOffice button at the left side of the top bar. So almost =

like the copies currently in the oxygen-iconset, cmp. e.g. the Karbon one:

http://websvn.kde.org/*checkout*/trunk/kdesupport/oxygen-
icons/64x64/apps/karbon.png?revision=3D976866

https://projects.kde.org/projects/calligra/repository/revisions/master/entr=
y/karbon/pics/app/hi64-
app-karbon.png

And in the last months it was even considered to come up with completely ne=
w =

app icons, which are easier to separate from each other and reflect more of =

the Calligra identity (whatever that is :) ).

So even if the now current Calliga app icons would move upstream to the =

oxygen-iconset as you proposed, they might be soon out-of-date again and th=
en =

shadow any new ones. So best really is to keep the icons close with the =

Calligra source and have them provided by Calligra itself.

Cheers
Friedrich

> > Hi,
> > =

> > tl;dr okay to remove Calligra app icons from oxygen iconset?
> > =

> > (follow-ups only to kde-artists@kde.org, thanks)
> > =

> > For the upcoming 2.6 release Calligra has been giving its apps some new,
> > slightly refined app icons (hi*-app-*.*).
> > =

> > Problem now is, the oxygen iconset also contains icons for at least tho=
se
> > apps which had not been renamed in the last two years (karbon, kexi,
> > krita)... Cmp. e.g.
> > http://websvn.kde.org/trunk/kdesupport/oxygen-icons/32x32/apps/
> > =

> > Which results in the fact that the new ones from Calligra will not be
> > used,
> > due to being shadowed by those in the oxygen-iconset. Not what is wanted
> > by
> > the Calligra devs, as you can imagine :)
> > =

> > Solution 1: simply update the icons in the oxygen iconset
> > =

> > That has the problem that Calligra is not part of the SC, and has as mi=
n.
> > KDE Platform dependency something old (even 4.3, well, known are at lea=
st
> > users that use the latest Calligra with KDE Platform 4.6). So no soluti=
on
> > with regards to them.
> > =

> > =

> > Solution 2:  install the app icons with a "calligra" prefix, e.g.
> > calligrakexi
> > =

> > Solves the shadowing by the icons in the oxygen-iconset, by now longer
> > having matching names. But that makes the icons in the oxygen-iconset
> > useless, as nothing will use them then.
> > =

> > Any better ideas?
> > =

> > To ensure consistent app icons the Calligra devs are currently consider=
ing
> > solution 2 for the upcoming 2.6 release. But as said, this also means t=
hat
> > the icons in the oxygen iconset are no longer needed and just bloat the
> > size of the iconset. So I would propose to remove these icons from
> > trunk/kdesupport/oxygen-icons:
> > =

> > oxygen-icons/48x48/apps/karbon.png
> > oxygen-icons/48x48/apps/kexi.png
> > oxygen-icons/48x48/apps/krita.png
> > oxygen-icons/128x128/apps/karbon.png
> > oxygen-icons/128x128/apps/kexi.png
> > oxygen-icons/128x128/apps/krita.png
> > oxygen-icons/64x64/apps/karbon.png
> > oxygen-icons/64x64/apps/kexi.png
> > oxygen-icons/64x64/apps/krita.png
> > oxygen-icons/22x22/apps/kexi.png
> > oxygen-icons/22x22/apps/krita.png
> > oxygen-icons/32x32/apps/karbon.png
> > oxygen-icons/32x32/apps/kexi.png
> > oxygen-icons/32x32/apps/krita.png
> > oxygen-icons/16x16/apps/karbon.png
> > oxygen-icons/16x16/apps/kexi.png
> > oxygen-icons/16x16/apps/krita.png
> > oxygen-icons/256x256/apps/karbon.png
> > oxygen-icons/256x256/apps/kexi.png
> > oxygen-icons/256x256/apps/krita.png
> > =

> > Maybe even from the 4.10 branch.
> > =

> > Does it make sense to have icons for non-SC apps in the basic
> > oxygen-iconset at all? Looking at the sources I see that there are icons
> > for a few for them, so it seems for most apps it is no problem at all to
> > serve their own app icons, which will usually be in oxygen style anyway.
> > =

> > Thoughts, opinions?
> > =

> > Cheers
> > Friedrich
> > _______________________________________________________________________=
___
> > __ __ kde-artists@kde.org | =

> > https://mail.kde.org/mailman/listinfo/kde-artists
___________________________________________________________________________=
___
kde-artists@kde.org |  https://mail.kde.org/mailman/listinfo/kde-artists